It wasn't DNA or facial recognition technology that cracked the case. Nor did amateur online investigators hunting for clues break it open.
In the end, it was a McDonald's restaurant employee - hours away from the scene of the crime - who spotted a man resembling a "person of interest" photo.
The suspect was careful to wear a mask while traveling around New York City, but pulled it down for a second to flirt with a woman behind the desk at a youth hostel, and again to eat at McDonald's.
That may have been enough.
Police in Altoona, Pennsylvania swooped into the restaurant and arrested Luigi Mangione, a 26-year-old from a wealthy Baltimore-area family with an expensive private and Ivy League education.
After six dramatic days, the hunt for the man suspected of shooting Unitedhealth CEO Brian Thompson was over.