Ofsted announced it would be scrapping its old single-word judgements for schools in 2024, following the death of head teacher Ruth Perry in January 2023. She had taken her own life after an Ofsted inspection which downgraded her school.
There had been a national outcry after Mrs Perry's death about the nature of school inspections, and a campaign to change the system by her sister Prof Julia Waters.
After announcing that the old system would be scrapped, the inspectorate said it would be replaced by the new report cards, which would be subject to a consultation period.
In September 2025, Ofsted said the new report card system would be implemented from November, despite claims from critics - including Prof Waters - that it had "failed to learn the lessons" from Mrs Perry's death, with a continuing "risk to the health and wellbeing of teachers and school leaders".
A legal challenge brought by the National Association of Head Teachers (NAHT) against the changes was thrown out by the High Court one week before the new system was introduced. The union later said it would consult its members on potential strike action.
The new system would be "better for parents" and "fair" to schools too, Ofsted's chief inspector Sir Martyn Oliver said following the court hearing.