This alternative has been increasingly popular, Ms Fitzpatrick said, adding that around 52% of the world's engagement rings now feature lab-grown diamonds.
Some customers are also opting for lab-grown for ethical reasons- but Ms Taylor said the debate is not as simple as it looks.
Lab-grown is not automatically more sustainable than natural mined stones, as the process uses a significant amount of energy.
Ms Taylor said some communities are financially dependent on the industry and rely on it for survival. There are, however, concerns over working conditions in diamond mines.
"As long as you are buying from a reliable source that's cleaning up the environment and looking after the communities involved," Ms Taylor said, "you have to decide, what's more important to you?"
She added that the ethics surrounding antique diamonds like Swift's are also complicated.
"Vintage can be more of an ethical choice, but its origin and story you don't necessarily know," Ms Taylor said.
Buying antique diamonds means no additional mining, but you also "have no idea what circumstances that was mined in", she added.
"If we're talking 100 plus years ago, that circumstance was probably not very nice."
Shoppers have increasingly turned to repurposing vintage pieces to create something more bespoke, Ms Faulkner said.
Couples will often choose to re-use jewellery with a "story behind it", she said, such as pieces that are passed down from relatives.
While it's not known whether Swift's ring has a backstory, she is clearly happy with the choice. But if her lyrics are anything to go by, it's the not most important thing.
"I like shiny things, but I'd marry you with paper rings," she sings in her song, Paper Rings.