NHS professional says 'let pupils wear trainers'

A healthcare professional from Sheffield has started a petition calling on schools to change their uniform policy regarding pupil's footwear.

Francesca Makey, lead orthotist at Sheffield Children's Hospital, argues schools need to change "outdated uniform policies" when it comes to forcing pupils to wear formal school shoes.

The NHS worker believes allowing pupils to wear trainers at school, instead of traditional, leather shoes would guard against potential discomfort, foot pain, and even knee problems in later life.

"A simple change in school uniform policy to permit plain black trainers could help protect the health of hundreds of thousands of children," said Ms Makey.

Over the course of her work at the Sheffield Children's Hospital, Ms Makey said she has helped a number of young pupils overcome issues with their feet.

An orthotist specialises in the fitting of orthoses (braces or splints) and bespoke footwear to help people with movement difficulties.

"I have witnessed first-hand the foot problems that can arise, or existing problems made worse, from wearing inappropriate school shoes," said Ms Makey.

"We routinely provide insoles and splints, but find it incredibly challenging to fit these into the standard, old-fashioned shoes required by most schools in the UK.

"Medical professionals consistently recommend trainers for growing feet, as they offer the necessary support, shock absorption and flexibility.

"Unlike hard shoes, trainers allow for natural foot movement and accommodate orthopedic aids far better, promoting long-term foot health and comfort," she added.

Whilst many primary schools in South Yorkshire do allow pupils to wear trainers, most secondary schools include formal black shoes as a requirement.

Katie Crook, associate vice principal at Penistone Grammar School, admitted uniform was a "topical discussion" within her school.

"We do have an inclusive policy on uniform - worked over years with stakeholders - broadly speaking a blazer, a tie, trousers or shorts, and smart black shoes"

"We're really proud to be part of a community here. We are one Penistone and wearing the uniform feels part of the community here.

"However, I think there are discussions to be had.

"The Department for Education usually offer advice and guidance, so we'd welcome that," she added.

"We're not archaic, we pride ourselves on inclusivity - but what is pivotal to our motto is that children represent the school."

"We don't want some pupils in £400 trainers, and others who can't afford it and feel uncomfortable about it."

Amira - who is now 14 years old - was born with over pronated feet, and some misplaced and missing bones. She has been a patient at Sheffield Children's Hospital since she was three.

When she was young, she didn't crawl for a long time and later found it challenging to play on climbing frames or run in the playground without severe pain.

She is now allowed to wear trainers at school and has a special lift pass.

"At certain times I feel a shooting pain through my feet - running and walking up stairs are difficult [and] in the playground, if I jump, it used to really hurt," she said.

Amira has a doctor's note that allows her to wear padded soft trainers with gel insoles at school.

"I feel like they should allow everyone to wear trainers, with or without medical issues - it's about being comfortable

"We're already in uniform, we're smart enough," she said.

Amira's mum, Rachel, agrees.

"If you're at work all day on your feet, wearing the same shoe it can be really tough.

"Children are the same, and their bones are still soft. You wouldn't be expected to be uncomfortable as an adult, I don't know why it's forced on children."

"Children coming out of school with a smile on their face is much more important than a tidy uniform."