Hospital and manager guilty over patient death

A hospital trust and a staff member have been found guilty of health and safety failings over the death of a young woman in a mental health unit.

Alice Figueiredo, 22, was being treated at Goodmayes Hospital, east London, when she took her own life in July 2015, having previously made many similar attempts.

Following a seven-month trial at the Old Bailey, a jury found that not enough was done by the North East London Foundation NHS Trust (NELFT) or ward manager Benjamin Aninakwa to prevent Alice from killing herself.

The trust was cleared of the more serious charge of corporate manslaughter, while Aninakwa, 53, of Grays in Essex, was cleared of gross negligence manslaughter.

The jury deliberated for 24 days to reach all the verdicts, setting a joint record in the history of British justice, according to the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS). Both the trust and Aninakwa were convicted under the Health and Safety at Work Act.

It was only the second time an NHS trust has faced a corporate manslaughter charge.

Speaking directly to Alice's mother and stepfather after the verdict, Judge Richard Marks KC said it was clear from the evidence that she was an extremely special young woman and "their immense love for her had been very apparent".

He also said he hoped they felt the case had been dealt with fully and that would "provide some consolation".

Alice was admitted to a mental health ward at Goodmayes Hospital in Ilford in February 2015.

She was under close observation on the Hepworth Ward, then managed by Aninakwa.

In the five months leading up to her death, she attempted suicide using plastic or bin bags on 18 occasions, mostly taking them from the same shared toilet, the Old Bailey heard.

The hospital had previously acknowledged the risk to patients of keeping bin bags on the ward and they were subsequently taken out of patient bedrooms.

However, despite warnings from Alice's family, they were not removed from the communal toilet, which was left unlocked.

On 7 July 2015, at her 19th attempt, she took her own life using a bin bag taken from the toilet.

During the trial, prosecutors said that not only was Alice repeatedly able to self-harm while she was in hospital, but that these incidents were not properly recorded or assessed.

The court also heard there were concerns about Aninakwa's communication, efficiency, clinical and leadership skills.

The trust had previously placed him on a performance improvement plan for three years, which ended in December 2014.

In addition, there was a high turnover of agency staff on the ward, the court heard.

Alice's mother Jane Figueiredo described the "intense pain" of being told about her death, saying it was the moment when "your entire life changes forever".

Her family prefer to remember the clever, creative, musical and funny young woman, who they say was full of life.

"She had the most amazing quick wit and sense of humour," Mrs Figueiredo said.

"She used to be able to make me laugh more than anybody in the world. And I really miss that."

Alice had experienced periods of deep depression since she was a teenager and also developed an eating disorder.

She was admitted to hospital on several occasions and her condition had always improved after treatment, her family said.

Her stepfather Max Figueiredo said it was a question of managing her illness and "trusting the medical profession to make the right decisions".

Mrs Figueiredo says she raised concerns about her daughter's care verbally and in writing on a number of occasions to the hospital and to Mr Aninakwa.

After Alice died, she said the family found it very difficult to get answers about what happened.

For nearly a decade they gathered evidence and pressed both the police and the CPS to take action.

Speaking after the verdict, Mrs Figueiredo said: "A wounded animal would have received safer, more attentive, compassionate care at the vets than Alice received on this ward.

"The final months of her life was a disastrous catalogue of dehumanising, at times miserably brutalising, neglectful experiences often lacking in compassion, vigilance and even basic humanity.

"It does not cost NHS hospitals and their staff more to be kind, compassionate and diligent within their duties."

NELFT is only the second NHS trust in England to have been charged with corporate manslaughter, with the only previous prosecution collapsing after two weeks.

It was particularly hard to bring corporate manslaughter charges against a large, complex organisation, said Dr Victoria Roper – an associate professor at Northumbria University, who studies this area of the law.

This was due to their complex organisational structures, said Dr Roper.

Corporate manslaughter charges were "reserved for the very worst management failings leading to death," she said.

The larger the organisation, the more difficult it was to show that senior management had had "any hands-on involvement in events".

However, she said public bodies, the police and the CPS would be keeping a close eye on this case to see what could be learned from it.

Alice's stepfather Max Figueiredo said the case had "moved the dial".

"Whilst disappointed that we have not reached the higher charges of corporate and gross negligence manslaughter in this case, we are glad that we did get the health and safety guilty verdicts," he said.

"The jury can only base their decisions on the evidence that was presented to them and the legislation in place.

"This decision took them two months to reach. We need a change in the law to allow for more clarity in these prosecutions and close the loopholes used by the defence teams."

A spokesperson for NELFT said: "Our thoughts are with Alice's family and loved ones, who lost her at such a young age. We extend our deepest sympathy for the pain and heartbreak they have suffered this past 10 years.

"We will reflect on the verdict and its implications, both for the trust and mental health provision more broadly as we continue to work to develop services for the communities we serve."

Mental health campaigners believe Alice's case highlights the poor care too many mental health patients receive.

Lucy Schonegevel, director of policy and practice at the mental health charity Rethink, said it was a "devastating reminder that we don't yet have a mental health system fit for the 21st century" and "people expect to be looked after and kept safe" on an in-patient unit.

But she said the charity was aware of many cases of patients being failed.

Alice's family believes any failing in cases such as hers must be transparent if they are to lead to improvements in mental health care, and they say they will keep pressing for that.

"It's never been about vengeance," Mr Figueiredo said. "It's always been about justice and truth and accountability. That's what has driven us."

The trust was found guilty of failing to provide mental health in-patient services in such a way as to ensure that persons not in its employment, namely the patients, were not exposed to risks to their health or safety.

Akinawa was found guilty of failure to take reasonable care for the health and safety of other persons affected by his acts or omissions at work.